II. Cold Pulsatile Machine Perfusion versus Static Cold Storage in Kidney Transplantation - A Single Centre Experience

  1. Please provide a summary of this article
4 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
98 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Balaji Kirushnan
Balaji Kirushnan
2 years ago

Delayed Graft function:

Delayed graft function is a known risk factor for overall poor allograft outcome..It is associated with reduced patient and graft survival…To improve the outcomes of DGF hypothermic machine perfusion(HMP) has been studied…In this study they compare the HMP with static cold storage…The underlying principle of this study is increase the release of nitric oxide and reduce the release of endothelin from the endothelium…This provides the reno protective effects and reduces the incidence of renal lesions in post transplant biopsies.

The retrospective study was conducted in the imperial college of London..They compared the effect of HMP versus static cold storage in deceased donor renal transplants…. They analyzed the DGF, LOS, eGFR and patient and graft survival…
33 patients with the HMP were compared to 33 Controls with either DBD or aged matched DCD patients in one center in 2012-2018..

They found that the DGF was lower in the HMP group 24% as compared to static cold storage 48%…. The overall patient and graft survival was similar…But those with HMP had a higher mean eGFR after 1 year…

The authors concluded that DCD kidneys do better on HMP as compared to cold storage due to high mean eGFR at 1 year and reduced incidence of DGF

Nazik Mahmoud
Nazik Mahmoud
2 years ago

Study that compare the cold storage of the kidney versus hypothermic perfusion machine in the rate of Delay graft function
cold ischemia time especially in deceased donation been the main risk factor for DGF and reducing the graft survival
they found the HPM had a good impact in kidney function and it is better than cold storage

Theepa Mariamutu
Theepa Mariamutu
2 years ago

Single-Centre retrospective analysis evaluated kidney transplant outcomes of hypothermic machine perfusion versus cold storage from March 2012 to April 2018.

Parameters evaluated

  • Delayed graft function,
  • Length of hospital stay,
  • estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR)
  • patient and graft survival
  • Renal Resistive Indexes (RIs)

hypothermic machine perfusion group had mean hypothermic machine perfusion time of 5.7 ± 3.9 hours with a mean cold ischaemic time of 15 ± 5.6 versus 15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group.

Delayed graft function was lower in the HMP group (p=0.041), and donation after Circulatory Death was a predictor for DGF (p<0.01).

hypothermic machine perfusion decreased Delayed graft function in DCD grafts (p=0.036).

Patient and graft survival were similar, but eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP cohort (p<0.001).

Renal Resistive Indexes decreased during hypothermic machine perfusion (p<0.01).

  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.45 mmHg/mL/min predicted Delayed graft function in DCD kidneys (75% sensitivity, 80% specificity; area under the curve 0.78);
  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.2mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DBD grafts (sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%; area under the curve 0.87)

hypothermic machine perfusion decreased Delayed graft function compared to cold storage, offering viability assessment pretransplant and improving one-year renal function of the grafts

Mohammed Sobair
Mohammed Sobair
2 years ago

Introduction:
Use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs.
Aim of the study:
 Study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single center experience.
Patients and Methods:
 Study is a single center retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys (RM3 Waters Medical System, US) transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only.
The case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients.
HMP was chosen as the preservation method.
 Result:
Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analyzed.
Mean HMP time was 5.7 ± 3.9 hours; in the HMP group, the mean CIT of 15 ± 5.6 hours and 15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group.
DCD was an independent predictor for DGF n both group of preservation.
 DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control cohort (p=0.036), confirming a protective effect of the HMP preservation for the grafts retrieved from DCD donors.
 The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had higher length of hospital stay.
The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP.
eGFRs for the HMP transplanted kidneys being persistently higher.
Discussion:
 DGF is the Achilles’ heel of kidney transplantation from DCD donors, affecting more than half of the subsequently grafts.
 Transplants from DCD kidneys the incidence of DGF was lower in the HMP compared to the CS cohort.
The use of cold pulsatile technology is a long-established alternative to static cold storage and it has been shown to be a better preservation method.
The use cold pulsatile perfusion devices, like the RM3 because of its potential Reno protective effect.
Conclusions:
 Within the limitations of the size of the HMP and CS groups, our study demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher post-transplant eGFRs.

Dalia Ali
Dalia Ali
2 years ago

the increasing demand for renal allografts and growing waiting lists has led to the utilization of organs through donation after Circulatory Death (DCD), although these organs are associated with higher rates of discard, retrieval associated injury   and up to 50% delayed graft function (DGF) in comparison to transplanted organs from donors after Brainsteam Death (DBD)

DGF is the Achille’s heel of kidney transplantation from DCD donors, affecting more than half of the subsequently transplanted grafts . Our findings demonstrated the protective role of HMP in this particular subcohort, related to reduced DGF rate. In our study, the incidence ofDGF was higher in the CS compared to the HMP cohort (p=0.041). For transplants fromDCD kidneys the incidence ofDGF was lower in the HMP compared to the CS cohort (p=0.036).

The use of cold pulsatile technology is a long-established
alternative to static cold storage and it has been shown to be a better preservationmethod . There are different types currently available for clinical kidney preservation; our policy is to use cold pulsatile perfusion devices, like the RM3 because of its potential renoprotective effect .

Knowing the risk profile of a particular kidney earlier in
the preservation process would be of great benefit for the postoperative management and it would provide objective information for selecting a particular recipient for a particular kidney, thus tailoring the offered renal replacement therapy to the patient who would benefit most. In the era of patient tailored consent and patient centred outcomes, it is mandatory to involve the transplant recipient and allow him/her to consider the risks related to increased chances of DGF if transplanted with kidney for which there is evidence that it is in such risk.

Conclusions
Within the limitations ofthe size of the HMP and CS groups, our studydemonstrated that hypothermicmachine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs. This preservation modality has a positive impact in kidney transplant outcomes from DCD donors and offers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short- and long-term posttransplant graft function. 

Hinda Hassan
Hinda Hassan
2 years ago

This is a retrospective cohort study that compared the transplant out-come of hypothermic machine perfusion(HMP) versus cold storage.It included 33 kidneys who had HMP and 33 who had cold storage. The cases were matched on 1:1 base according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time and HLA mismatch. It has been conducted in a single centre from 2014-2018.they used the DGF definition of  the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft.for GFR , they used the  mean Modification of Diet in Renal Disease estimated glomerular filtration rate of the first 365 days after transplant. The study showed that HMP was associated with lower DGF and Renal Resistive Indexes   and  with a higher eGFR at 365 days in DCD grafts.

Ahmed Omran
Ahmed Omran
2 years ago

DGF is considered more than 50% of transplant graft. studies proved the role of HMP in reducing DGF.
Cold pulsatile method is the preferred method in high risk kidneys, as reduces rate of DGF and is associated with higher posttransplant graft function.
It is better to know risk of kidney pre preservation process which had impact on DGF
47 patients with a transplant were followed up for more than 365 days: 20/33 and 27/33 in the HMP and CS cohorts; respectively., repeated eGFRs of multivariate analysis of univariate measures showed significant difference between the HMP and the CS groups and the eGFRs for the HMP transplanted kidneys were higher. Use of perfusion machine technology reduced DGF particularly DCD organs. The study showed that the HPM had an advantage of reduced DGF rate& better post-transplantation graft function in DD renal transplantation.

CARLOS TADEU LEONIDIO
CARLOS TADEU LEONIDIO
2 years ago
  1. Please provide a summary of this article

DGF is a risk factor for reduced graft and patient survival, reducing its rates is a major challenge, making ideal organ preservation a highlight. DGF includes several pathophysiologic mechanisms derived from donor ischemic injury and inflammatory signaling, and animal studies have demonstrated that one of the main benefits of using cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation is attributed to improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced endothelin secretion, resulting in a renoprotective effect, not achievable with standard static cold storage. This would be the great benefit of the hypothermic perfusion machine.

The main flow monitoring parameter of the Hypothermic Perfusion Machine is the Renal Resistance Index, which allows a real-time assessment of organ recovery.

This study sought to evaluate the relationship between DGF , resistance index and cold ischemia time. And it demonstrated the protective role of the Hypothermic Perfusion Machine in its subcohort in particular, related to the reduction of the DGF rate. 

rindhabibgmail-com
rindhabibgmail-com
2 years ago

This is a single center cohort analysis study done from 2012 to 2018 for analysis of hypothermic perfusion machine versus cold storage only.
The aim of study was to compare both techniques, in this study the incidence of DGF was higher in the cold storage system compared to hypothermic perfusion machine.
As animal studies showed that cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation may result a reno-protective effects.
The use of perfusion machine technology reduces DGF particularly DCD organs. the study shows that the HPM has the advantage of reduced DGF rate and higher post-transplantation graft function in deceased donor renal transplantation.

Hussam Juda
Hussam Juda
2 years ago

Introduction
·        The use of machine perfusion technology may reduce DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs
·        Animal studies found that using cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation, may result in a reno-protective effect
·        The aim of the study to compare between the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation, and static cold storage
 
Patients and Methods
·        The study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only
·        cold ischaemic time (CIT) is the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time
·        DGF was defned as the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft
 
Results and Discussion
·        Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed.
·        No statistical diference was observed between the HMP and CS group baseline characteristics
·        DGF patients had higher length of hospital stay
·        In this study, the incidence of DGF was higher in the CS compared to the HMP cohort  
·        For transplants from DCD kidneys the incidence of DGF was lower in the HMP compared to the CS cohort
·        Elevated renal Resistive Index indicates parenchymal injury, and monitoring of RI may help to estimate the risk of developing DGF
·        The present study found that the HMP associated with a significant higher eGFRs at 365 days of follow up in comparison with CS group
 
Conclusions
·        Limitations: the size of the HMP and CS groups
·        Hypothermic machine perfusion has the advantage of reduced DGF rates and higher posttransplant eGFRs in risky deceased donor renal transplantation 

MILIND DEKATE
MILIND DEKATE
2 years ago

Worldwide increasing demand of renal allograft and increasing waiting list has led to utilization of organs through donation after cardiac deaths.
These organs are associated with higher rates of discards, retrieval associated injuries and up to 50% incidence of DGF as compared to DBD organs.

The optimal organ preservation remains one of the major challenges to reduce the current DGF rates.

promisingly the use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates , particularly in DGF organs.

Hence authors has done retrospective single Centre cohort analysis of Hypothermic Machine Perfused kidneys with matched cold storage only.

And they found that DCD kidneys developed DGF in HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in Cold Storage group. (P value was 0.036).

The DCD was independent risk factor for development DGF in the whole cohort.

A 2-hours RI value of more than or equals to 0.45 mmHg/ml/min was associated with DGF prediction for DCD graft, with sensitivity of 75 %, specificity of 80 % and the area under curve was0.78.

The patient receiving graft with subsequent DGF had higher length of hospital stay, 11.6 +/- 5 days versus 29.1 +/-18.1 days (p < 0.001).

They concluded that HMP (Hypothermic Machine perfusion) offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it significantly reduces the DGF rates and is associated with higher post – transplantation eGFR.

Farah Roujouleh
Farah Roujouleh
2 years ago

Method :  single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys (RM3 Waters Medical System, US) transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only
 case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients.
 
Result :
No statistical difference was observed between the HMP and CS group baseline characteristics: mean recipient’s age, cause of kidney failure, numbers of grafts from DCD and DBD donors, number of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient, donor’s age and CIT
The DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control cohort
The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had higher length of hospital stay
The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP:
 
Conclusion :
the hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation
of high risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs
 

AMAL Anan
AMAL Anan
2 years ago

DGF is considering more than half of transplant graft
studies showed role of HMP IN reducing DGF
Cold pulsatilla method is better method in high risk kidneys, as reduces rate of DGFand is associated with higher posttransplant graft
It is better to know risk of kidney pre preservation process
Which has impact on DGF
47 patients with a transplant follow up more
than 365 days: 20/33 and 27/33 in the HMP and CS cohorts
respectively.
repeated
eGFRs of multivariate analysis of univariate measures showed a
signifcant difference between the HMP and the CS groups while the
eGFRs for the HMP transplanted kidneys still
higher

Esraa Mohammed
Esraa Mohammed
2 years ago

1. Introduction

DGF is a well-established risk factor associated with
reduced long-term graf and patient survival furthermore, recipients transplanted with kidney grafs that develop
DGF face prolonged hospitalization and the overall relevant

increased costs. Promisingly, the use of machine perfusion

technology has been associated with improved DGF rates,
particularly for DCD organs.

2. Patients and Methods

Te study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of
hypothermic machine perfused kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only

Te case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to
graf type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time
(CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA)
mismatches between donor and recipients.

All the patients received a steroid sparing immunosuppressive regimen (7-day course of steroids) with alemtuzumab induction and long-term Tacrolimus (TAC) monotherapy (trough level, 5-8 ng/mL) and neither the renal replacement therapy nor the immunosuppression protocol of our centre changed over the last 10 year

3. Statistical Analysis
Analysis was performed using SPSS

4. Results
No statistical difference between Cold Storage and Hypothermic Machine perfusion, but delaye d graft function was lower in HMP specialy in DCD group.

5. Conclusions
Within the limitations of the size of the HMP and CS groups,study demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion ofers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it reduces signifcantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs

Hamdy Hegazy
Hamdy Hegazy
2 years ago

This is a retrospective study conducted by one center in the USA to compare the renal graft outcomes between hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) method and standard cold storage.
This study collected data for renal transplants from March 2012 till April 2018 with 33 cases had HMP and 33 cases had standard cold storage.
This study compared the two groups mainly regarding the following parameters:  Cold ischemia time, Delayed graft function, Resistive index, MDRD e-GFR, length of hospital stays and graft failure. 
Results:
1-   No difference in CIT between two groups.
2-   No difference in patient and graft survival.
3-   DGF in DCD transplants was lower in HMP group.
4-   e-GFR within 12 months was higher in HMP group.
5-   RI120> 0.45 mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DCD transplants.
6-   RI120>0.2 mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DBD transplants.
Limitations:
1-   Small study size.
2-   Single Center.
3-   Retrospective. 
Level of evidence: III

Conclusion:
HMP is associated with reduced DGF and higher e-GFR post-transplant especially in DCD kidneys. 

Huda Saadeddin
Huda Saadeddin
2 years ago

Introduction

Worldwide, the increasing demand for renal allografts and growing waiting lists has led to the utilization of organs through donation after Circulatory Death (DCD), although these organs are associated with higher rates of discard, retrieval associated injury ,and up to 50% delayed graft function (DGF) in comparison to transplanted organs from donors after Brainsteam Death (DBD).

The use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs.

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single centre experience.

Results 

No statistical difference was observed between the HMP and CS group baseline characteristics: mean recipient’s age, cause of kidney failure, numbers of grafts from DCD and DBD donors, number of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient, donor’s age and CIT.

Discussion

DGF is the Achille’s heel of kidney transplantation from DCD donors, affecting more than half of the subsequently transplanted grafts .
Our findings demonstrated the protective role of HMP in this particular subcohort, related to reduced DGF rate. In our study, the incidence of DGF was higher in the CS compared to the HMP cohort (p=0.041). 
For transplants from DCD kidneys the incidence of DGF was lower in the HMP compared to the CS cohort (p=0.036).

The use of cold pulsatile technology is a long-established alternative to static cold storage and it has been shown to be a better preservation method.

There are different types currently available for clinical kidney preservation; our policy is to use cold pulsatile perfusion devices, like the RM35 because of its potential renoprotective effect .
This particular technology results in better preservation of the endothelial integrity and recovery, with improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1 in exvivo models .
In this way, the underlying mechanisms of DGF are actively repaired, with a substantial difference from static cold preservation.

the use of HMP resulted in the lower incidence of DGF, especially in the challenging DCD group, and higher eGFRs observed for HMP kidneys.

Another advantage that the pulsatile technology provides is a platform during which the graft could be actively reconditioned, making it particularly attractive for higherrisk kidneys ,as it delivers oxygenation, or any other nutrients or reconditioning agents, and creates a window of opportunity during which to assess the viability and quality of the graft before transplantation.

Conclusions

Within the limitations of the size of the HMP and CS groups, our study demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs. This preservation modality has a positive impact in kidney transplant outcomes from DCD donors and offers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short- and long-term posttransplant graft function.

Marius Badal
Marius Badal
2 years ago
  1. Please provide a summary of this article

The article is about cold pulsatile machine perfusion versus static cold storage in kidney transplantation a single-center experience that was very interesting. Worldwide there is a huge demand for donors and organs for transplantation and what little amount is available every method of preservation is necessary to ensure graft survival. So organ preservation has been a challenge over the years, but newer techniques may help reduce the current problem of DGF and reduce rejecting kidneys. Implementing the machine perfusion will help to improve the DGF especially from DCD donors and as such decrease hospitalization, cost, etc. 
The aim of this article was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation when compared with static cold storage based on a single-centre experience. 
The method used was one that was:
1)    A single-center retrospective cohort study that compared the effect of HMP versus cold organ storage organ preservation. 
2)   The case-control match one on one by the graft type DCD or DBD, the age, CIT, and the HLA mismatches.
3)   The HMP solution was the university of Wisconsin with a temperature of 4-5 degree Celsius with a systolic pressure of about 45mmHg.
4)   After 30 minutes of cold perfusion the pressure continued to be constant at above 40 mmHg and the RI was recorded to help to monitor the kidney parenchymal function.
From the study, there were 66 transplanted kidneys that were analyzed, and found that the mean CIT for HMP and cold storage were 15 +/-5.6 hours and 15 +/- 5.3 hours. The DGF rate was about 5/12 versus 10/12 in HMP versus the CS group after organ retrieval from DCD. It was found that the RI was statically decreased during the HMP. Also, the higher GFR level after 365 days was associated with HMP. The DGF group was higher in the CS group when compared with the HMP which was lower. It was noted that the renal parenchymal was damaged from DCD but lower in the HMP users.
So from the study one can deduce that DGF was less with HMP when compared with CS and the GFR was better with the HMP after a year. As such HMP was more protective and as such can give researchers a better option to choose and to get a better outcome for the graft.

Mahmud Islam
Mahmud Islam
2 years ago

With the increased demand for deceased donors to increase the donor pool, we need to preserve renal function with the least risk of AKİ, DGF etc. In this study, though the number of patients is low, hypothermic machine perfusion was superior to cold storage (CS). 33 patients with HMP were matched with 33 patients with CS as two groups. As summarized in table one, there is heterogenicity between causes of ESDR. we do not know the exact HLA mismatch profile, but generally, both groups are nearly similar in this context.
DCD donation was found as an independent predictor of DGF. The resistive index (a marker of microcirculation) decreased over time while patients were on the machine, as shown in figure 1. As shown in table 3, DGF was significantly higher in the CS group. similar result was shown for DCD group.

Hussam Juda
Hussam Juda
2 years ago

INTRODUCTION
 
·        Donated organs after DCD, associated with 50% delayed graft function (DGF) in comparison to DBD donated organs
·        DGF is a risk factor for reduced long-term graft and patient survival.
·        The use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs
·        The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single centre experience
 
Patients and Methods
·        The study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only.
·        The case controls were according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and HLA mismatches between donor and recipients.
·        Definitions:
-CIT: the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time.
-DGF: the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft.
 
Results
·        DGF was statistically significantly higher in the Cold Storage group and in DCD grafts.
·        Patient and graft survival were similar, but eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP cohort
 
Conclusions
·        This study found that hypothermic machine perfusion is superior in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, as it reduces DGF rates and has higher posttransplant eGFRs.
 
Limitation: Small sample groups

Dr. Tufayel Chowdhury
Dr. Tufayel Chowdhury
2 years ago

Introduction:

DCD organs are associated with 50% of DGF in comparison to DBD.The process underlying DGF include several pathophysiologic mechanisms derived from the donor ischemic injury and inflammatory signalling.The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage.

Patients and Methods:

The study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only.

The case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients.

CIT was defined the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time. DGF was defined as the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft.

All the patients received a steroid sparing immunosuppressive regimen (7-day course of steroids) with alemtuzum- ab induction and long-term Tacrolimus (TAC) monotherapy.

 

Results:

Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed. Nostatistical difference was observed between the HMP and CS group baseline characteristics: mean recipient’s age, cause of kidney failure, numbers of grafts from DCD and DBD donors, number of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient, donor’s age and CIT.

The DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control cohort (p=0.036), confirming a protective effect of the HMP preservation for the grafts retrieved from DCD donors.

The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had higher length of hospital stay (LOS): 11.6 ± 5.8 days versus 29.1 ± 18.1 days (p<0.001).

The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP.

 

Limitation:

Small size

Conclusions:

This study demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys.

 

Assafi Mohammed
Assafi Mohammed
2 years ago

Summary of the article
Cold Pulsatile Machine Perfusion versus Static Cold Storage in Kidney Transplantation – A Single Centre Experience.

This is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys, during kidney transplant preservation, in comparison to static cold storage based on a single centre experience.

The study results and outcomes:
1.    The DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control cohort, confirming a protective effect of the HMP preservation for the grafts retrieved from DCD donors.
2.    The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP.
3.    The incidence of DGF was higher in the CS compared to the HMP cohort. For transplants from DCD kidneys the incidence of DGF was lower in the HMP compared to the CS cohort 
4.    The study findings demonstrated the protective role of HMP, related to reduced DGF rate. 
5.    The study demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high-risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs. 

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Assafi Mohammed
2 years ago

That is a good summary, dear Dr Assafi.

saja Mohammed
saja Mohammed
2 years ago

Introduction
 Due to increased demand for organ donation with prolog waiting list the use of donation after circulatory death (DCD) has been exploited despite the many challenges including  higher rate of organ discard, Ischemic injuries with associated higher risk of DGF, so optimal organ preservation considered one of the important factors to reduce the risk of CIT and DGF rate, reduce prolonged hospital stay a and  overall   costs. According to the literatures  the HMP technology found to have impact  on the organ preservation and reduction in the rate of DGF from DCD and ECD. This is retrospective study addresses the renal transplant outcome with the use of HMP reservation vs standard cold solution from single center from UK     
 
Methods
Retrospective  cohort from single center, study period march 2012-2018
Matching 1:1 based on graft type DCD VS DBD with donors  and recipients’ demographics
 They included 33 HMP kidney transplant and compared with the outcome of matched 33 cold stored, with the primary outcome was DGF,
Renal RI during HMP and its correlation to DGF, length of hospital stays (LOS), e GFR and also compared  both patient and graft survival as outcome between the two groups up on the FU period with median fu of365 days  
Donors and recipients’ demographics were recorded   including age, sex, BMI, comorbid, numbers of HLA mismatches  
CIT defined from the time of cold perfusion during organ retrieval until reperfusion time during transplantation including HMP time.
DGF identified by the need for HD with in first week post transplantation with perfused organ.
Using MDRD formula for calculation of GFR  
Definition of graft failure, censored for death and return back to dialysis.
Immunosuppression, induction with alemtuzumab  with steroid sparing protocol (only for 7 days steroids), maintenance includes tacrolimus monotherapy with target trough level 5-8ng/ml
Results
66 transplant kidneys outcome underwent analysis
 No difference was observed between the HMP and CS  group
Mean HMP time was 5.7 +/-3.9 hours   with similar CIT   in the two groups. after linear regression model only, the DCD was found as significant independent prognosticator for increased risk of DGF in 36% in all cases and even higher in CS group 48% which mirror the protecting effect of HMP conservation for the graft retrieval from DCD donors.
 Patients with DGF  they have longer stay in the hospital, RI significantly lower during the HMP with mean RI at baseline of 0.65and after 1 hour was 0.62 and after 120 minutes was only 0.46
In subgroup analysis the 2 hours RI value > 0.2 mmgh /ml/min was  100% sensitive and > 90% specific for predicting DGF for DBD donors while 2 hours RI value > 0.45 mmgh /ml/min was   only 75% sensitive and 80% specific in predicting DGF from DCD.
 Upon FU we have total 47 patients completed > 356-day FU and the e GFR was significantly higher in HMP group

Discussion
 In this cohort the use of the  HMP preservation have protective effect  by reducing the DGF incidence ,and  even lower DGF rate  from DCD donors with the use of pulsatile HMP  technology  even better than static Sold storage preservation process due to its Reno protective effect with less endothelial injury, improved nitic oxide release and lower the expression of endothelin 1 in ex vivo module  and resulted to reduce the DGF rate and better graft outcome .another advantages of such technology   is  to actively reconditioned the marginal graft as it delivered oxygen and other nutrient , reconditioning agents all give chance to improve the quality and viability of the graft  pre-OP.  RIs another indicator of tissue injury which can be monitor   by HMP technology usually the higher RIs  indicate the higher chance of DGF or PNF and its more after DCD donation as it reflects the microvascular injury and associated with poor outcome.
Conclusion
In this case control cohort we can conclude that Pulsatile HMP preservation technology in ECD, DCD had  Reno protective due to significant   lower  rate of DGF and shorter hospital study with better  kidney transplant outcome.
Limitation
Small sample size, single center, short follow-up

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  saja Mohammed
2 years ago

That is a good summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’

Hussein Bagha baghahussein@yahoo.com
Hussein Bagha baghahussein@yahoo.com
2 years ago

This was a single center retrospective study looking at hypothermic pulsatile machine perfusion versus cold static storage in kidney transplantation.
Introduction:
Due to the widespread shortage of kidneys for transplant, DCD donors are increasingly being utilized to reduce the waiting times on the kidney transplant list. Kidneys from DCD donors are associated with higher rates if discard, retrieval injury and DGF. DGF is a well-established risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival. There is also the increased and length of stay and increased hospital costs for recipients who develop DGF. Animal studies have demonstrated that one of the main benefits of using cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation, is attributed to the improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin 1. One of the flow parameters in HMP, the renal RIs, has been previously identified as a marker of the whole-organ microcirculatory damage after retrieval ischemic injury. Monitoring RI could also provide a real time evaluation of the organ recovery during HMP.
Methodology
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single center experience.
The study is a single center retrospective cohort analysis HMP kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018.
The case controls were matched on a 1:1 basis according to graft type DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischemia time, and number of HLA mismatches.
The University of Wisconsin solution was used for HMP at a temperature of 4-5 degrees Celsius and at an initial systolic pressure of 45 mmHg. RIs were recorded to monitor kidney parenchymal recovery.
CIT was defined as the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant including HMP time.
DGF was defined as the need for dialysis within one week of transplantation with a perfused graft.
The mean MDRD eGFR was compared until day 365 from transplantation and the length of hospital stay between the two groups.
Graft failure, censored for death, was defined as permanent return to dialysis.
Results
66 kidney transplant outcomes were analyzed.
The mean HMP time was 5.7 hours. The mean CIT in the HMP group was 15 hours and in the cold storage group it was 15.1 hours.
DCD was an independent predictor for DGF (p<0.01) in the whole cohort, occurring in 24/66 (36%): 8/33 (24%) machine perfused and 16/33 (48%) in cold stored (p=0.036)
The DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS group (p=0.036)
The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had higher Length of hospital stay
The RI decreased significantly during HMP: mean RI at baseline was 0.65, after 60 min was 0.62, after 120 min was 0.46, and after 180 min was 0.42.
47 patients had a transplant follow up longer than 365 days. Multivariate analysis of univariate repeated eGFRs showed a statistically significant difference between HMP and CS groups with the eGFRs for the HMP transplanted kidneys being higher.
Discussion:
The findings demonstrate the protective role of HMP related to reduced DGF rate for both DBD and DCD donors. The kidneys that underwent HMP had a higher eGFR compared to the ones that had CS. The RIs progressively lowered in the HMP showing that there was recovery of parenchymal injury.
Conclusion:
The HMP has an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation compared to CS. It significantly reduces DGF rates and is associated with higher post-transplant eGFRs. It also offers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short and long term post-transplant graft function.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin

 I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Huda Mazloum
Huda Mazloum
2 years ago

● (DCD) are associated with higher rates of discard, retrieval associated injury and (DGF) in comparison to (DBD)
● Optimal organ preservation remains one of the major challenges to reduce current DGF rates
● Use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with
* improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs
* higher posttransplant eGFRs
* ofers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short- and long-term posttransplant graft survival
● The main benefts of using cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation, is to improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1 resulting in a renoprotective effect
● Renal Resistance Index (RI) is a marker of whole-organ microcirculatory damage after the retrieval ischaemic injury
● The aim of the study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to standered cold storage
● Incidence of DGF was higher in the CS compared to the HMP
● Protective short- and long-term efect of HMP.
● Pulsatile technology provides a platform during which the graft could be actively reconditioned, making it particularly attractive for higher-risk kidneys
● Increased RIs are associated with donation afer Circulatory Death and donor age 

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Huda Mazloum
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply. Please type headings and subheadings. And these should be in bold or underline so that it is easier to read.

Last edited 2 years ago by Ajay Kumar Sharma
abosaeed mohamed
abosaeed mohamed
2 years ago

This is a single centre experience comparing hypothermic machine perfusion vs cold storage in relation to kidney transplant outcome. By Retrospective analysis of 33 consecutive HMP kidney transplant outcomes matched with those of 33 cold stored: delayed graft function, length of hospital stay, estimated glomerular filtration rate, and patient and Graf survival were compared. Renal Resistive Indexes during HMP in relation to DGF were also analysed. DGF decreased with perfusion machine , graft survival & outcome were similar but eGFR after one year was better in perfusion machine groups .conclusion is that HMP decreased DGF compared to CS, offering viability assessment pretransplant and improving one-year renal function of the grafts

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  abosaeed mohamed
2 years ago

I like your short summary.

KAMAL YOUSIF ELGORASHI ADAM
KAMAL YOUSIF ELGORASHI ADAM
2 years ago

Cold Pulsatile Machine Perfusion vs Static Cold Storage in Kidney Transplantation: A Single Center Experience:
Introduction:
Globally with increasing demand of grafted kidneys, which lead to utilization of marginal kidneys, DCD, and ECD. Although poor quality kidney may associate with DGF and long-term increased risk of graft loss, but it overweighs the risk associated with chronic dialysis and recipient on waiting list.
So optimal organ preservation is the major challenges to maximize utilization of such kidneys, to reduce current DGF rate, and to reduce the discarded kidneys.
Recipient from deceased kidneys with poor quality had a higher rate of DGF, and prolonged hospitalization, and increasing cost, for that use of machine perfusion improved the rate of DGF, especially from DCD donors.
Methods:

  1. Single center retrospective cohort analysis, of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys transplanted vs cold storage only. from 2012 to 2018 in US.
  2. Case control were matched 1:1 basis on the (graft type DBD or DCD, donor age, CIT, HLA MM.
  3. HMP was used as preservative method, at temperature 4-5 C, and SBP of 45 mmHg, with recorded IRs.
  4. CIT defined as the time from the start of cold perfusion to the time of reperfusion, including MP.
  5. DGF defined as the need of dialysis during the first week of Tx, with a perfused graft.
  6. eGFR was measured using MDRD, until 365 days after Tx.
  7. LOS between 2 groups.
  8. Graft failure
  9. Censored for death.
  10. All patients receive steroid sparing immunosuppressive regiment, With Alemtuzumab induction, and long-term TAC monotherapy, (trough level, 5-8 ng/ml), for 10 days.

Results:

  1. DCD was an independent risk factor for GDF, in the whole cohort.
  2. 24/66 kidneys machine perfused.
  3. 16/33 kidneys were cold stored.
  4. DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP were 5/12 vs 10/12 in the CS control cohort, confirming a protective effect of HMP preservation for grafted kidneys from DCD donor over CS.
  5. The RI reduced significantly during HMP, mean RI at base line was 0.65 +/- 0.25 mmHg/ml/min, after 60 min was 0.62 +/- 0.33 mmHg/ml/min, after 120 min was 0.46 +/- 0.16 mmHg/ml/min, after 180 min was 0.44 +/- 0.22 mmHg/ml/min, the higher impact in decreasing the original RI value was observed between 1st and 2nd hours of HMP.
  6. 2 Hrs RI value of >/0.2 mmHg/ml/min was associated with 100% sensitivity and 91% specificity in DGF prediction of DBD graft, the area under the curve was 0.87.
  7. 2 Hrs Ri value of >/0.45 mmHg/ml/min, was associated with 75% sensitivity and 80% specificity, in DGF prediction for DCD graft, the area under the curve was 0.78.
  8. 47 patients had a transplant follow-ip more than 365 days; 20/33 and 27/33 in the HMP and CS cohort respectively.
  9. eGFR was persistently higher in HMP group.
  10. At 180 days; 1 graft loss due to acute rejection, while 3 graft were lost in CS group.

Discussion;

  1. DGF is the from DCD donors affecting more than 50% transplanted graft.
  2. HMP had a protective rule in decreasing DGF.
  3. Long standing method, cold pulsatile, shown to be a better preservative method than CS.
  4. Use of HMP resulted in a lower incidence of DGF, especially in challenging DCD group.
  5. eGFR was higher in HMP donor with follow-up period of 365 days and this is reflected short- and long-term benefit of HMP.
  6. Presence of parenchymal damage in the kidneys from DCD donors demonstrated by a higher RIs at 2 Hrs post HMP.
  7. DGF was associated with longer HS.

Conclusion;
Thid study show that HMP exert its +ve effects on improving DGF, and associated with higher eGFR.
Limitations of the study;

  1. Retrospective cohort.
  2. Small group study.
  3. Shorter duration of follow-up.
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  KAMAL YOUSIF ELGORASHI ADAM
2 years ago

That is a good summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’

Mohamed Mohamed
Mohamed Mohamed
2 years ago

II. Brain death & care of the organ donor
1. Please provide a summary of this article
The AAN defined brain death with 3 main signs: – Cessation of brain functions that include
 Brainstem
– Coma  or unresponsiveness
– Apnea
Globally great differences exist in criteria & the tests used.
Prerequisites required before testing for brain death include:
Proximate cause for unresponsiveness that is incompatible with survival: Major trauma, intracranial bleed with midline shift.
Imaging to confirm diagnosis: CT brain, MRI, angiography.
Exclude conditions that could account for
unresponsiveness: severe acid-base, metabolic or electrolyte abnormalities.
Exclude drugs causing unresponsiveness: Sedatives, narcotics, muscle relaxants. In overdose allow time for 5 half-lives/measure drug levels.
Normal temperature: Core temp >32°C/90°F.
Clinical testing for brain death
1. Coma: no response to noxious stimulus
(supraorbital pressure or nail bed pressure) with the exception of spinal reflexes.
2. Absent brain stem reflexes:
-Pupillary light reflex: afferent II CN,
 efferent III CN nerve
– Corneal reflex: afferent V CN, efferent
 VII nerve
– Reflexes in the face & maxillary region: area
 by V CN (trigeminal)
Oculo-cephalic reflex (doll’s eye movement):
 afferent VIII, efferent III & VI. Lateral 90°
 movements of neck result in deviation of eyes
 to opposite direction with an intact brain stem;
 rule out cervical spine injury prior to testing
– Oculo-vestibular reflex: afferent is VIII &
 efferent III & VI CNs; patient at a 30° head up
  position (lateral semicircular canal becomes
 vertical),50 ml of ice-cold NS injected into ear.
 Nystagmus with a slow component toward the
side of injection indicate functioning brain stem (assure intact tympanic membrane. Wait 5 min before testing other ear)
– Pharyngeal (gag) & laryngeal (cough) reflex):
 afferent IX & efferent X CNs
3. Apnea test: checks integrity of brain stem respiratory center at high CO2.
Prerequisites prior testing are: normothermia (core temp ≥36.5°C), SBP ≥100 mmHg, no sedative & paralytic drugs, normal oxygenation (PaO2 ≥200 mmHg after 100% oxygenation) & near normal PaCO2 (35-45 mmHg).
Steps:
– Disconnect ventilator
– O2 given at 6.0 L/min
– Look respiratory movements 8-10 min after
  Disconnection
– Positive test if no respiratory movements at
  PaCO2 of 60 mmHg (20 mmHg above baseline
  if initially high)
– Certify brain death after a 2nd apnea testing
  (timing widely varies between centers).
– Time of death is when PaCO2 reaches target
  value during 2ndapnea test.
Problems during apnea test
1. The test aborted & repeated if SBP is ≤90 mmHg; vasopressors & fluid needed to keep it above target.
2. SaO2 not maintained during apnea testing:
The test cancelled if SaO2 is ≤85% for >30 s. Retest with T-piece & CPAP of 10 cm H2O & O2 flow 12.0 L/min.Tolerance to apnea can be predicted by reducing the PEEP to 5 cm H2O before ventilator is disconnected.  
3. Hypothermia (<36.5°C): repeat test after correction.
4. Repeatedly de-saturation or hypotension testing: ancillary tests (EEG, angiography, trans-cranial Doppler & scintigraphy) considered to confirm brain death.
5. Baseline PaCO2 ≥40: test is +ve if a rise by ≥20 above baseline.
6. Baseline PaCO2 ≤35: reduce ventilation frequency to raise PaCO2 to target before testing.
Ancillary tests to support a brain stem death
– Used if neurologic evaluation is uncertain or apnea test cannot be done.
– 4 vessels digital subtraction angiography is the gold standard for CBF testing: absence of filling at carotid bifurcation or vertebral arteries confirms brain death.
– CT angiography: safer alternative & accurately test CBF.
– Transcranial Doppler: used in ICU, is simple & noninvasive. It is operator dependent.
– EEG: widely used to document brain death. Isoelectric recording over 30 min is suggestive.
(sedatives & hypothermia give similar picture).
– Cerebral tissue perfusion (technetium 99 m)
study is used in some centers.
If clinical findings are unreliable, the physician can decide against brain death rather than asking for ancillary tests (AAN recommendations).
Care of Organ Donor
– Needs the same intensity of care.
– Focus treatment (inotropes, fluids) toward
  organ perfusion & improved quality of grafts.
– Potential donor: brain-dead or with severe
  brain injury with a clear intent by physician
 & the family to withdraw life support.
– Grief counselors can communicate with the
  family & act in the interests of both the
  potential donor & the pool of recipients.
Pathophysiology & organ preservation 
·The hormonal & inflammatory changes that accompany brain death can cause graft dys-function & increased chances of rejection.
·Increased awareness, in recent decades, of donor management has improved outcomes after transplant surgery.
CVS
·Medullary ischemia occuring with brain death causes a reflex HTN & bradycardia (Cushing’s reflex) in an attempt to maintain the CBF.
·This is followed by intense vasoconstriction & tachycardia (dt increased catecholamines) which increase visceral & myocardial ischemia.
·Echocardiogram indicated in all potential donors.
·Pulmonary artery catheterization indicated if EF <45% (cardiac & lung transplants).
·Goals of management:
– maintain BP with minimal inotropes
– optimize fluid management
-maintenance organ perfusion.
Respiratory system
·Endogenous epinephrine raises pulmonary hydrostatic pressure causing endothelial damage & pulmonary edema.
·Goals of ventilatory management:
– Minimal FiO2 to maintain a PaO2 >100, SpO2 >95%, PaCO2-35-40 & pH 7.35-45.
– Ventilation strategies similar to those used for ALI are currently recommended & have improved the use of lungs for transplant.
-Excessive fluid to correct perfusion can result in pulmonary edema. Use of a PAC may restrict fluid use.
– Albuterol & diuretics can be used in the treatment of pulmonary edema.
Endocrine system & metabolic responses
·DI: due to early loss of posterior pituitary function in brain death. Causes polyuria & hypernatremia. AVP & desmopressin are used as replacements.
·Thyroid hormones decreased (sick euthyroid state).
·Decrease in insulin & worsening of hyper-glycemia with stress, alteration in CHO metabolism & use of glucose solutions. Hyperglycemia induced pancreatic cell damage compromise pancreatic graft; strict euglycemia may minimize the risk. Hyperglycemia also affect outcomes after renal transplant.
·Temperature regulation in hypothalamus: initial hyperthermia followed by hypothermia (worsened by lack of shivering, peripheral vasodilatation & reduced metabolic rate). Hypothermia aggravates acidosis & coagulopathy & increase risk for arrhythmias & cold-induced dieresis.
SIRS
Caused by inflammatory mediators from ischemic brain, IRI, & catecholamine storm.
Increased IL-6 in the donor have poorer graft utilization & dysfunction.
DIC: occurs dt release of tissue thromboplastin from necrotic brain tissue.
Donor management protocols
·The “Rule of 100” normal targets:
-SBP ≥100 mmHg
-UOP ≥100 ml/h
-Hb ≥100 g/L
-PaO2 ≥100 mmHg
-Blood sugar 100mg/dl
·Core temp. >35°C prior to donation (circulating hot air blankets, warm IV fluids, ambient temp. adjustment.
·Fluid management (patients are polyuric &
   dehydrated with central volume depletion):
-Crystalloids: balanced salt solutions (Ringer’s lactate, Plasmalyte-A, Ringer’s acetate, ½ NS with NaHCO3 may be superior to NS bcz as they do not cause hyperchloremic acidosis.
-Uncorrected hypernatremia can cause  in liver graft losse after transplant.
-Hydroxyethylstarches contraindicated bcz they damage renal epithelial cells & cause early graft dysfunction in renal grafts.
-PAC may allow restrictive strategy with monitoring of filling pressures in lung transplant.
-Blood  & blood products: follow guidelines for the care of the critically; hemoglobin of 10 g/L improves tissue oxygenation.
·Inotropes & CVS:
– Dopamine has beneficial effect on renal graft probably due to moderation of preservation injury & inflammation (not reno-protective).
-Noradrenaline (>0.05 mcg/kg/min) impair cardiac contractility in heart transplants.
·Ventilatory management:
-Similar to ALI (low tidal volume 6-8 ml/kg, minimum plateau pressure, lung recruitment).
-Lowest FiO2 needed is used
-Optimal PEEP with a restrictive fluid strategy improves graft harvesting in lung transplants.
·Replacement of hormones:
– Vasopressin 1 U bolus, then infusion 0.5-4.0 U/h.
– Methylprednisolone 15 mg/kg immediately after brain death & 24 hourly after.
– Insulin 10 U in 50% dextrose, then infusion (keep blood glucose 80 – 150 mg).
– T4 20 mcg bolus, then infusion of 10 mcg/h. T3 (4-mcg bolus, then infusion 3 mcg/h).
UNOS data showed that the combination of thyroid hormone, corticosteroid, insulin & ADH was the best for multiple organ procurement.
Infections
·Sepsis, bacteremia or fungemia in the donor are not absolute contraindications to donations.
·HIV infections, herpetic meningo-encephalitis & T-cell leukemia-lymphoma virus are contraindications to donation.
Other concerns
Pregnant patient who is brain-dead:
The mother should be supported until the fetus delivered & then considered organ donation.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Mohamed Mohamed
2 years ago

That is a detailed summary.

Last edited 2 years ago by Ajay Kumar Sharma
Isaac Abiola
Isaac Abiola
2 years ago

SUMMARY

Introduction
In spite of the growing demand for kidney donor globally, the rate of discard of kidney from donation after circulatory death is still with about 50% incidence of delay graft function in those that were eventually used. One of the leading factors to the above challenge is the mode of preservation of retrieved organs either by cold storage or hypothermia machine perfusion. Animal studies on HMP has been very promising in preserving the organ better than cold storage.

Aim

  • to evaluate the impact of HMP during kidney transplantation against cold storage in preservation of the organ

Methodology

  • single centre retrospective cohort study
  • comparing the effect HMP vs cold storage on organ preservation.
  • case controls were matched 1:1 by graft type (DCD or DBD), age, CIT, and HLA mismatches
  • university of Wisconsin solution was used for HMP, at a temperature between 4-5∘ C and at an initial peak systolic pressure of 45 mmHg.
  • following 30 minutes of cold perfusion, the pressure was held constant ≥ 40 mmHg.
  • RIs were recorded to monitor kidney parenchymal recovery

Results

  • 66 transplanted kidney outcomes were analyzed
  • the mean CIT for HMP and cold storage were 15 _+ 5.6 hours and 15 _+ 5.3 hours
  • the rate of DGF was 5/12 vs 10/12 in HMP vs CS group following organ retrieval from DCD.
  • the RI was found to statically decrease during HMP
  • higher eGFR level after 365 days was associated with HMP using post-oc
  • DGF was significantly higher in CS group compared to HMP group in which it was lower
  • parenchyma damaged in kidney from DCD was noted to more, but still found to be lower in organ using HMP for preservation

Conclusion
The journey of kidney transplant comprises of both short term and long outcome, proper preservation of organ using HMP is key and has been shown to reduce the DGF and increase eGFR level even after 360 days post transplantation. Nevertheless, patients need to be counsel on the type on the source of the organ they are receiving so as to make an informed decision

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Isaac Abiola
2 years ago

That is a good summary.

Nahla Allam
Nahla Allam
2 years ago

Introduction :

Ø DGF is a risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival; furthermore, recipients transplanted with kidney grafts that develop DGF face prolonged hospitalization and the overall relevant increased costs. Machine perfusion technology has improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD.

Ø The process underlying DGF includes several pathophysiologic mechanisms derived from the donor ischemic injury and inflammatory signaling; the clinical manifestation of the acute kidney injury affects the transplant parenchyma and, subsequently, renal function.

Ø One of the flow parameters in HMP, the Renal Resistance Index (RI), has been previously identified as a marker of whole-organ microcirculatory damage after the retrieval of ischaemic injury . Monitoring RI could also provide a real-time evaluation of organ recovery during HMP.

The aim of this study :
Ø To evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation compared to static cold storage based on a single-center experience.
Patients and Methods

Ø The study is a single-center retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine-perfused kidneys (RM3_ Waters Medical System, US) transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only. Analysis was performed using SPSS (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 20.0;  IBM Corp, Armonk, NY).

Results:

#This study analyzed Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes.

The mean HMP time was 5.7 } 3.9 hours; in the HMP group, the mean CIT of 15 } 5.6 hours, and 15.1 } 5.3 hours in the CS group (p=ns).

#DCD was an independent predictor for DGF (p<0.01) in the whole cohort, occurring in 24/66 kidneys (36%): 8/33 (24%) machine perfused and 16/33 (48%) cold stored (p=0.041).

#The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had a higher length of hospital stay (LOS): 11.6 } 5.8 days versus 29.1 } 18.1 days (p<0.001).

The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP: mean RI at baseline (R0) was 0.65 } 0.25 mmHg/ml/min (p<0.01); after 60 minutes (RI60) was 0.62 } 0.33 mmHg/ ml/min (p<0.01); after subanalyses the difference in RIs between DCD and DBD grafts. A 2-hour RI value ≥ 0.2 mmHg/ml/min was associated with 100%sensitivity and 91% specificity in DGF prediction for DBD grafts. The area under the curve was 0.87

#Forty-seven patients had a transplant follow-up longer than 365 days: 20/33 and 27/33 in the HMP and CS cohorts, respectively.

Post hoc tests using the Bonferroni correction revealed that higher values of eGFRs at day 365 were associated with HMP perfusion (p<0.001)

#One graft loss occurred in the HMP group at 180 days due to acute rejection; 3 grafts were lost in the CS cohort: venous thrombosis (n=1) at 120 days posttransplant and acute rejection (n=2), at 180 days posttransplant (p=0.31).

# One patient died in the HMP group with a nonfunctioning graft after 270 days posttransplant due to myocardial infarction; no patient died in the CS (p=0.32)

Conclusions

the limitations of the size of the HMP and CS groups demonstrated that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high-risk kidneys since it significantly reduces DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Nahla Allam
2 years ago

That is a good summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this HMP and CS groups’

Abdul Rahim Khan
Abdul Rahim Khan
2 years ago

 Please provide a summary of this article
Because of increasing demand due to renal transplant waiting list, there is increasing trend to donation after circulatory death. DCD can be associated with higher risk of discard of organ. There is 50 % higher risk of DGF with DCD as compare do brain stem death.
Machine perfusion- HMP  is associated with less risk of DGF and injury due to reperfusion.
Methodology
This was a retrospective study of 33 HMP kidney transplant outcomes compared with 33 cold storage -CS. Variable checked-
Delayed graft function (DGF)
Length of hospital stay
Estimated glomerular filtration rate
Patient and graft survival
Renal Resistive Indexes (RIs) during HMP in relation to DGF
 
Results.
eGFR at 1 year was higher with HM than cold storage and resistive index decreased  during HMP
DGF was less common in HMP group
DGF was more with DCD than DBD
 
Conclusion
DGF is less with HMP as compared to CS
eGFR is better with HMP
 
Limitations
Retrospective study
Small sample
Single centre

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Abdul Rahim Khan
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply. I like your list of limitations of this study

Wael Jebur
Wael Jebur
2 years ago

A retrospective study of 33 deceased donor kidneys to evaluate the the impact of Hypothermic machine perfusion HMP in comparison to 33 deceased donor kidneys preserved with cold store. The short and long term outcomes of the two methods were emphasized in relation to DGF, length of stay in the hospital, eGFR, as well as patient and graft survival.
Owing to the increasingly adopted practice of transplanting the DCD kidneys with its inherent compromised function and the subsequent risk of DGF which might be hovering over 50% of all case , the methods of procurement were developed to overcome this common complication.

Wael Jebur
Wael Jebur
Reply to  Wael Jebur
2 years ago

The ischemic injury related to DCD is commonly associated with DGF {50% of DCD in comparison to DBD} with its detrimental consequences on the long-term outcome of the allografts, Hence, the optimization of the allograft condition with a perfect Methode to minimize the ischemic damage and improve the risk of AKI is the key to a successful transplantation.
It was found that the HMP is linked to improved endothelial the intigrity by augmenting the release of nitric oxide and diminish the release of Endothelin I release which consequently optimize the microcirculation perfusion and minimize the resistive index which is utilized as a surrogate marker for microcirculatory flow and damage thereof.
This study compared the outcome of using HMP vs the conventional Cold storage in preserving the allograft and reducing the risk of having consequent DGF.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Wael Jebur
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Wael Jebur
2 years ago

Your reply is short though logical, dear Dr Jebur.

Sherif Yusuf
Sherif Yusuf
2 years ago

Deceased donor transplantation is associated with high risk of DGF; around half of the cases develop DGF after transplantation. DCD is associated with higher incidence of DGF

Machine perfusion was found to decrease the risk of DGF and ischemia reperfusion injury as it increase the endothelial release of nitric oxide, decrease the secretion of endothelin-1, and provide oxygenation to the graft. Moreover it allows for testing of the kidney viability.

This is a retrospective study in a single center evaluating 33 transplant recipients using kidneys preserved by oxygenated pulsatile hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP- RM3) and compared them to 33 cold storage (CS) renal recipients after matching of the cold ischemia time (around 15 ± 5 hours) regarding DGF, estimated GFR at 1 year, resistive index in relation to DGF, length of hospital stay, graft and patient survival

Results:

  • DGF is more common in patients after DCD compared to DBD patients
  • DGF was less common in HMP when compared to CS transplant recipients
  • RI decreased during HMP
  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.45 mmHg/mL/min in DCD kidneys was 75% sensitive and 80% specific for prediction of DGF, while in DBD kidneys
  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.2 mmHg/ml/min in DBD kidneys was 100% sensitive and 91% specific for prediction of DGF.
  • Estimated GFR at 1 year was higher in HMP when compared to CS transplant recipients

Conclusion

  • HMP is associated with decrease in  the incidence of DGF and improvement of GFR after 1 year when compared to CS (HMP  has a protective rule) and can predict the occurrence of DGF with good sensitivity and specificity, moreover HMP allow for the assessment of viability of the kidney so it the best way for kidney preservation especially in high risk kidneys
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Sherif Yusuf
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Abhijit Patil
Abhijit Patil
2 years ago

Summary:

Introduction.

The study evaluated kidney transplant outcomes of hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) versus cold storage (CS)

Methods.

  • Single-centre retrospective analysis
  • March 2012 to April 2018
  • The case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients
  • 33 HMP kidney transplant outcomes matched with those of 33 cold stored grafts
  • The University of Wisconsin solution was used for HMP, at a temperature between 4-5°C and at an initial peak systolic pressure of 45mmHg. After 30 minutes of cold perfusion, the pressure was held constant = 40 mmHg. RIs were recorded to monitor kidney parenchymal recovery.
  • Parameters evaluated
  • delayed graft function (DGF),
  • length of hospital stay (LOS),
  • estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR)
  • patient and graft survival
  • Renal Resistive Indexes (RIs)

Results.

  • HMP group had mean HMP time of 5.7 ± 3.9 hours with a mean cold ischaemic time (CIT) of 15 ± 5.6 versus 15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group.
  • DGF was lower in the HMP group (p=0.041), and donation after Circulatory Death (DCD) was a predictor for DGF (p<0.01).
  • HMP decreased DGF in DCD grafts (p=0.036).
  • Patient and graft survival were similar, but eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP cohort (p<0.001).
  • RIs decreased during HMP (p<0.01);
  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.45 mmHg/mL/min predicted DGF in DCD kidneys (75% sensitivity, 80% specificity; area under the curve 0.78);
  • 2-hours RI ≥ 0.2mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DBD grafts (sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%; area under the curve 0.87)

Conclusion.

HMP decreased DGF compared to CS, offering viability assessment pretransplant and improving one-year renal function of the grafts

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Abhijit Patil
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Reem Younis
Reem Younis
2 years ago

Please provide a summary of this article
-Donation after Circulatory Death (DCD) associated with higher rates of discard, retrieval associated injury , and up to 50% delayed graft
function (DGF) in comparison to transplanted organs from donors after Brainsteam Death (DBD) .
– DGF is a well-established risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival .
– Promisingly, the use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs .
-One of the flow parameters in HMP, the Renal Resistance Index (RI), has been previously identified as a marker of the whole-organ microcirculatory damage after the retrieval ischaemic injury .Monitoring RI could also provide a real time evaluation of the organ recovery during HMP .
-The study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys (HMP) transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only. It was conducted in accordance with institutional ethics regulations; since it was a retrospective chart analysis, no informed consent was required.
-The study demonstrated the protective role of HMP in this particular subcohort, related to reduced DGF rate.
-The use of cold pulsatile technology is a long-established alternative to static cold storage and it has been shown to be a better preservation method .
-Cold pulsatile perfusion devices have potential renoprotective effect. It results in better preservation of the endothelial integrity and recovery, with improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1 in exvivo models .
-In this way, the underlying mechanisms of DGF are actively repaired, with a substantial difference from static cold preservation.
-The use of HMP resulted in the lower incidence of DGF, especially in the challenging DCD group, and higher eGFRs observed for HMP kidneys consistently during the 365 days of follow-up; this demonstrates the protective short- and long-term effect of HMP.
– The pulsatile technology provides is a platform during which the graft could be actively reconditioned, making it particularly attractive for higher risk kidneys , as it delivers oxygenation, or any other nutrients or reconditioning agents, and creates a window of opportunity during which to assess the viability and quality of the graft before transplantation .
-RIs are known to rise in parallel to the development of parenchymal injury  and increased RIs are associated with donation after Circulatory
Death and donor age .
-In the  study, the prevalence of the parenchymal damage in kidneys from DCD donors was demonstrated by the higher renal Resistive Index at 2 hours post HMP: 0.2 mmHg/ml/min for DBD versus 0.45 mmHg/ml/min for DCD.
-The present study showed that the HMP cohort had significantly higher eGFRs at 365 days of follow up when compared to the CS group.
– The advantages demonstrated in this study by the use of HMP are associated with better outcomes related to those important social and economic aspects .

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Reem Younis
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply. Please type headings and subheadings. And these should be in bold or underline so that it is easier to read.

Sahar elkharraz
Sahar elkharraz
2 years ago

This article focus on comparison between hypothermic machine perfusion and static cold storage based on a single centre retrospective cohort study. It’s done between March 2012 to April 2018; 
The cold ischemic time defined as time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time. 
DGF was defined as the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused grafts. eGFR done for all patients.
All the patients received a steroid sparing immunosuppressive regimen (7-day course of steroids) with alemtuzumab induction and long-term Tacrolimus with target level, 5-8 ng/mL. RI estimated for all patients during machine perfusion.
Pulsatile cold ischemic time is renoprotective and reduce rate of DGF. This study shows the incidence of DGF was higher in the cold storage compared to the HMP. For transplants from DCD kidneys the incidence of DGF was lower in the HMP compared to the cold storage.
The use of cold pulsatile technology is a long established alternative to static cold storage and it has been shown to be a better preservation method. HMP technique results in better preservation of the endothelial integrity and recovery, with improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1. It’s reduced and repairing DGF especially in donor with DCD. RIs are demonstrate of the microcirculatory damage occurring within the parenchyma [11]; so the stress induced by the circulatory arrest is linked to a worse profile. This study shows hypothermic machine perfusion has advantage in preserve deceased donor especially DCD with raising eGFR and reduce rate of DGF and length stay in hospitals in comparison to cold storage.
.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Sahar elkharraz
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Nandita Sugumar
Nandita Sugumar
2 years ago

Summary
Cold pulsatile machine perfusion vs cold static storage

This study works on the basis of organ preservation to prevent DGF. DGF can have a significant impact in the long term in the form of deceased long term graft and patient survival.

Major benefit of cold pulsatile machine perfusion is associated with the release of nitric oxide from endothelial cells and decreased release of endothelin- I. This can lead to a protective effect for the kidneys. This is not achieved in cold static machine perfusion.

DGF is more commonly associated with DCD donors.
HMP has a protective effect possibly towards preventing DGF in the graft. This is particularly seen in the case of DCD donor kidneys.

RI is a predictor for the development of DGF in the graft. RI can rise in parallel to development of parenchymal injury. This is because they are an expression of microcirculatory damage occurring within the parenchymal cells.
Increased RI is associated with donation following circulatory death and donor age.

Understanding the risk profile of a kidney before deciding the storage and preservation method is helpful for post op management.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Nandita Sugumar
2 years ago

I like the scientific contents of your reply.

Shereen Yousef
Shereen Yousef
2 years ago

This Retrospective study based on a single centre study was done to compare HMP kidney transplant with cold storage

▪︎Introduction
shortage of organs and long waiting list resulted in increasing acceptance of organs after Circulatory Death and after Brainsteam Death.
optimal organ preservation is a major challenges to reduce current DGF and improve long-term impact.

DGF is a risk factor that reduces graft and patient survival , increasing hospitalization time and costs.

DGF was defined as the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft.

CIT is time from start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time.

machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs.

using cold pulsatile perfusion for preservation, improves endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1, resulting in a renopro-tective effect, not like standard static cold storage.

▪︎Patients and Methods
33 consecutive HMP kidney transplant outcomes matched with those of 33 cold stored
case controls were matched on 1:1 basis
According to donor type ,CIT,HLA mismatch.
All patient’s had a steroid sparing protocol (7-day with alemtuzumab induction and (TAC) monothapy (trough leve5-8 ng/mL).

▪︎Results

Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed.

mean HMP time was 5.7 ± 3.9 hours, with a mean cold ischaemic time of 15 ± 5.6 while in CS group it was 15.1 ± 5.3 hours .

DCD was independent risk factor for DGF 

DCD kidneys developed DGF in  HMP group was 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control group,so DGF was less in the HMP group,even with DCD 

HMP preservation had more protective effect for DCD grafts.

DGF was associated with longer hospital stay.

Resistive Index  was significantly lower during HMP.

eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP group.

Patient and graft survival was equal in both groups 

▪︎Conclusion

HMP preservation decreased incidence of DGF in both DCD  and brain stem death compared to cold storage,

cold pulsatile perfusion devices like RM3 has renopro-tective effect.

This technology resulted in better preservation of endothelial integrity and better recovery of endothelial function and increase release of nitric oxide with decrease of endothelin-1 that lead to repair of underlying mechanisms of DGF 

The graft could be actively reconditioned, with good opportunity to assess viability and quality of graft before Tx.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Shereen Yousef
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I like the scientific contents of your reply. Please type headings and subheadings in bold or underline so that it is easier to read.

Shereen Yousef
Shereen Yousef
Reply to  Ajay Kumar Sharma
2 years ago

Thank sir i will try doing so next time

Mahmoud Wadi
Mahmoud Wadi
2 years ago

II. Cold Pulsatile Machine Perfusion versus Static Cold Storage in Kidney Transplantation – A Single Centre Experience

  1. Please provide a summary of this article

====================================================================

  • DGF is a well-established risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival , further more, recipients transplanted with kidney grafts that develop.
  • DGF face prolonged hospitalization and the overall relevant increased costs .
  • Promisingly, the use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs .
  • The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single centre experience.

==============================================================

Patients and Methods

  • The study is a single centre retrospective cohort analysis of hypothermic machine perfused kidneys (RM3 Waters Med- ical System, US) transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage only.
  • The case controls were matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients.
  • CIT was defined the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time.
  • DGF was defined as the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft. Furthermore, we compared the mean Modification of Diet in Renal Disease estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) until day 365 from transplantation and the length of hospital stay (LOS) between the two groups. Graft failure, censored for death, was defined as permanent return to dialysis.

All the patients received a steroid sparing immunosup pressive regimen (7-day course of steroids) with alemtuzumab induction and long-term Tacrolimus (TAC) monotherapy (trough level, 5-8 ng/mL) .
=============================================================

Results

  • Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed.
  • No statistical difference was observed between the HMP and CS group baseline characteristics: mean recipient’s age, cause of kidney failure, numbers of grafts from DCD and DBD donors, number of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient, donor’s age and CIT.
  • The mean HMP time was 5.7 ± 3.9 hours; in the HMP group, the mean CIT of 15 ± 5.6 hours and 15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group (p=ns).
  • In a linear regression model with stepwise procedure, DCD was an independent predictor for DGF (p<0.01) in the whole cohort, occurring in 24/66 kidneys (36%): 8/33 (24%) machine perfused and 16/33 (48%) cold stored (p=0.041).
  • The DCD kidneys that developed DGF in the HMP group were 5/12 versus 10/12 in the CS control cohort (p=0.036), confirming a protective effect of the HMP preservation for the grafts retrieved from DCD donors.
  • The patients receiving grafts with subsequent DGF had higher length of hospital stay (LOS): 11.6 ± 5.8 days versus 29.1 ± 18.1 days (p<0.001).
  • The RI decreased statistically significantly during HMP: mean RI at baseline (R0) was 0.65 ± 0.25 mmHg/ml/min (p<0.01); after 60 minutes (RI60) was 0.62 ± 0.33 mmHg/ ml/min (p<0.01); after 120 minutes (RI 120) was 0.46 ± 0.16 mmHg/ml/min (p<0.01); after 180 minutes (RI180) was 0.44 ± 0.22 mmHg/ml/min (p<0.01).
  • The higher impact in decreasing the original RI value was observed between the first and the second hour of HMP (p< 0.01).
  • Forty-seven patients had a transplant follow up longer than 365 days: 20/33 and 27/33 in the HMP and CS cohorts respectively.
  • Repeated eGFRs measures showed a statistically significant difference between the HMP and the CS groups (p=0.039), with the eGFRs for the HMP transplanted kidneys being persistently higher .
  • Post hoc tests using the Bonferroni correc-tion revealed that higher values of eGFRs at day 365 were associated with HMP perfusion (p<0.001)
  • One graft loss occurred in the HMP group at 180 daysdue to acute rejection; 3 grafts were lost in the CS cohort: venous thrombosis (n=1) at 120 days posttransplant and acute rejection (n=2), at 180 days posttransplant (p=0.31).
  • One patient died in the HMP group with a nonfunctioning graft after 270 days posttransplant due to myocardial infarction; no patient died in the CS (p=0.32).

====================================================================

Conclusions


Within the limitations of the size of the HMP and CS groups,

  • Hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys, since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs.
  • This preservation modality has a positive impact in kidney transplant outcomes from DCD donors and offers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short- and long-term posttransplant graft function.
  • It represents a real time opportunity to recondition the retrieval ischaemic injury, plan the postoperative recovery, and enhance the decision-making process by offering the patients evidence that allow them to make an informed decision.

====================================================================

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Mahmoud Wadi
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this HMP and CS groups’.

Mohammad Alshaikh
Mohammad Alshaikh
2 years ago

Please provide a summary of this article

Introduction:
Delayed graft function is the need for HD within one week of transplant is a complication of interest in deceased donor either DBD or DCD- transplants, almost 50% of DCD -transplanted patients experience DGF, i has been related to reduced long term outcome of the transplanted kidney and incraesed the risk of rejection.
This study comparing the impact of hypothermic machine perfusion vs static cold storage on DGF.

Primary end points were :
= Cold ischemia time (CIT) defined as the time from the start of cold perfusion till the of reperfusion after transplant.
= Delayed graft function(DGF) defined as the need for dialysis within a week of transplant.
= Length of hospital stay
= eGFR -MDRD till 365 days post tx.
= Graft failure censored death defined as the permanent return to dialysis.

Method:
Retrospective case cohort of 66 kidney transplantation from deceased donors (33 MHP group and 33 CS group)were selected and matched on 1:1 basis according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time (CIT), and number of Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatches between donor and recipients, in a single center.( the variables were comparable)
Resistive index (RI) were measured to evaluate for graft parenchymal recovery in both groups.
All recipients received steroid sparing immnuosupressive, alemtuzumab, and tacrolimus monotherapy(trough 5-8 ng/ml).

Results:
= DCD was an independent predictor for DGF (p<0.01) in the whole cohort.
= DGF occurs in 8/33 (24%) machine perfused and 16/33 (48%) cold stored (p=0.041).
= Recipients acquiring DGF had higher length of hospital stay: 11.6 ± 5.8 days versus 29.1 ± 18.1 days (p<0.001).
= A 2-hours RI value ≥ 0.2 mmHg/ml/min was associated with 100% sensitivity and 91% specifcity in DGF prediction for DBD grafts.
= A 2-hours RI value ≥ 0.45 mmHg/ml/min was associated with 75% sensitivity and 80% specifcity in DGF prediction for DCD grafts.
=  Repeated eGFRs measures showed a statistically significant difference between the HMP and the CS groups (p=0.039)- persistently favoring HMP.
= There were no difference between two groups in graft loss or patient survival.

Limitations:

  • small group of patients.
  • single center.

Conclusion:
HMP provides prevention of DGF over the CS, in both DCD and DBD.
HMP had consistently higher eGFR level at short and long time(365 days).
The retrieval ischaemic injury, plan the postoperative recovery, and enhance the decision-making process by offering the patients evidence that allow them to make an informed consent.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Mohammad Alshaikh
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Hadeel Badawi
Hadeel Badawi
2 years ago

Organ preservation remains one of the major challenges to reducing DGF rates and the relevant detrimental long-term impact. The use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates, particularly for DCD organs. 

Aim of the study: evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation compared to static cold storage. 
Outcome measures: DGF, length of hospital stay (LOS), eGFR, and patient and graft survival were compared.

Patients and Methods;
Design: single-center retrospective cohort analysis of HPM kidneys transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018
versus cold storage only. 
The case controls were matched on a 1:1 basis.
Machine parameters, including RIs were recorded to monitor kidney parenchymal recovery.
CIT: the time from the start of cold perfusion during organ retrieval to the time of reperfusion during the transplant, including the HMP time. 
DGF; the need for dialysis within 1 week of transplantation with a perfused graft. 

Results:
Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analyzed;  33 in HPM and 33in CS group. 
The mean HMP time was 5.7 ± 3.9 hours; in the HMP group, the mean CIT of 15 ± 5.6 hours and 15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group. 
DCD was an independent predictor for DGF, and DGF was lower in HPM group.
Patients who developed DGF had higher LOS. 
RIs decreased during HMP ; 2-hours RI ≥ 0.45 mmHg/mL/min predicted DGF in DCD kidneys (75% sensitivity, 80% specificity; area under the curve 0.78); 2-hours RI ≥ 0.2mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DBD grafts (sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%; area under the curve 0.87). 
eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP.
Patient and graft survival were similar.

Conclusion:
HMP significantly reduces DGF compared to CS. This modality positively impacts kidney transplant outcomes from DCD donors, offers viability assessment pre-transplant, and improves the one-year renal function of the grafts. 

Limitations:
Small sample size. 
Single center study. 
Retrospective nature 

Level 3 evidence retrospective case-control study

Despite the evidence is not strong, the result is encouraging, and further larger study is needed.  

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Hadeel Badawi
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Filipe Prohaska Batista
Filipe Prohaska Batista
2 years ago

This is a single-center retrospective cohort study between March 2012 and April 2018 comparing machine perfusion with cold storage comparing brain or cardiovascular dead donors, age, cold ischemia time, and HLA mismatches.
Perfusion machine maintains a temperature between 4 to 5 degrees Celsius, with peak systolic 45mmHg and vascular resistance control.

Of the 66 transplanted kidneys, 24 were from donors with cardiovascular death and DGF, 8 in a perfusion machine, and 16 in cold storage, with a better statistical response of the graft in the patients of the first group. At the end of the first year after transplantation, these data were even more robust, showing that graft function is also better after one year of transplantation.

The findings of this study show that patients who used a perfusion machine had a better graft response when compared to cold storage, even in higher-risk groups, such as donors for cardiovascular death. Control of the perfusion machine on flow, pressure, oxygenation, and vascular resistance had a positive impact, even after one year of transplantation. The study also talks about the economic impact of patients with FGD on prolonged hospital stays, the need for greater interventions, and additional care.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Filipe Prohaska Batista
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary.

Filipe prohaska Batista
Filipe prohaska Batista
Reply to  Ajay Kumar Sharma
2 years ago

Thank you, Professor

Mohamed Saad
Mohamed Saad
2 years ago

Cold Pulsatile Machine Perfusion versus Static Cold Storage in Kidney Transplantation: A Single Centre Experience.
Using organs from DCD is great resource or donation but still DGF is one of the most common problem due to perfusion defect and prolonged CIT which is considered risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival, so the role of the use of machine perfusion technology appear in scene which lead to cold pulsatile perfusion that has role in preservation, is attributed to the improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1.
Aim of the study.
To evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single center experience.
Patients and Methods.
Retrospective cohort analysis of 33 consecutive HMP kidney transplant outcomes (transplanted from March 2012 to April 2018) matched with those of 33 cold stored: delayed graft function (DGF), length of hospital stay (LOS), estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), and patient and graft survival were compared. Renal Resistive Indexes (RIs) during HMP in relation to DGF were also analysed.
Result.
-DCD was an independent predictor for DGF and DGF was more in CS group.
-The more DGF the more length hospital stay.
-e GFR follow up longer than 365 days was higher than in HMP group than those in CS group.
-One graft loss in HMP group versus three in CS group.
Limitation of the study:
-Single center study.
-Small size of sample.
-Short follow up duration.
Conclusion:
HMP technology results in better preservation of the endothelial integrity and recovery, with improved endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1, and has good effect of the graft survival and patient survival and decreasing DGF in DCD.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Mohamed Saad
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Mohammed Abdallah
Mohammed Abdallah
2 years ago

Please provide a summary of this article

Introduction

DGF is a well-known risk factor associated with reduced long-term graft and patient survival

To reduce the risk of GFT and improve outcome, optimal organ preservation is required

Aim of the study: a retrospective cohort study to compare the effect of HMP preservation with static cold storage (CS). DGF, length of hospital stay (LOS), eGFR, and patient and graft survival were compared

Methods

33 HMP kidney transplant compared to 33 CS (match 1:1) in one center (2012-2018)

Case control match was according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, CIT, HLA mismatches between donor and recipients

Results

Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed (33 HMP and 33 CS)

The mean HMP time was 5.7 ± 3.9 hours; in the HMP group, the mean CIT of 15 ± 5.6 hours and15.1 ± 5.3 hours in the CS group

DGF was lower in the HMP group: 8/33(24%) HMP and 16/33 (48%) CS

DCD was an independent predictor for DGF, occurred in 24/66 kidneys (36%)

HMP decreased DGF in DCD grafts

Patient and graft survival were similar, but eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP cohort

Those who developed DGF had higher length of hospital stay

Discussion

In the study for transplant DCD, DGF was lower in HMP when compared to CS. Higher eGFRs in HMP kidneys consistently during the 365 days of follow-up

RI is an independent predictor during HMP for the later development of DGF and can estimate the risk of a kidney to develop DGF

Conclusion

When compared to CS, HMP reduces DGF significantly and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs

HMP has a positive impact in kidney transplant outcomes from DCD donors and predict short and long-term posttransplant graft function

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Mohammed Abdallah
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary.

Mohamad Habli
Mohamad Habli
2 years ago

DGF is a recognized risk factor associated with decreased graft and patient survival over the long term. To get the best possible outcome from each donor kidney and maximize the survival benefit relative to the dialysis population, effective organ preservation continues to be one of the greatest obstacles to reducing current DGF rates and their resultant negative long-term impact.

Methods
This is a single center, retrospective cohort study evaluated the effect of HMP on the kidney preservation in comparison to static cold storage.
A total of 66 transplanted kidney outcomes were assessed for a duration of 6 years.
Case controls were matched according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischemic time, and number of HLA mismatches.
Patients received a steroid sparing immunosuppressive regimen with alemtuzumab induction and long-term Tacrolimus monotherapy.

Results
Sixty-six transplanted kidney outcomes were analyzed. Results of the study as follow:
– DGF affect fifty percent of DCD donors.
– The incidence of DGF was observed to be greater in CS than in HMP.
– Cold pulsatile technique is a superior preservation method alternative to static CS.
– Use of HMP is related with a decreased incidence of DGF, particularly in DCD patients with a higher eGFR over a one-year follow-up ( hort & long term protective effect of HMP).
– Pulsatile technology can recondition the graft, making it suitable for kidney transplants with a higher risk (deliver O2, nutrients, or reconditioning agents).
– The study demonstrates a correlation between parenchymal damage and RI 2 hours after HMP.
– The study demonstrates that the advantages of HMP in terms of improved social and economic outcomes are significant.
 
In conclusion, this research showed that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys. This is due to the fact that it significantly lowers DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs. However, study was limited by the fact that the HMP and CS groups were both relatively small.

mai shawky
mai shawky
2 years ago

Club 2; cold pulsatile machine perfusion vs static cold storage
Summary:
·       Current study is retrospective cohort, from single center, involving aimed to compare the DDKT outcomes including DGF and its consequences as hospital stay duration, eGFR  at 1 year follow up, long term graft and patient survival between cold machine perfusion and static cold storage.
·       It is better to use especially in DCD to decrease incidence of DGF as it was found in exvivo studies that it decreases the release of endothelin and increase NO which leads to renal artery vasodilatation and maintain in renoprotection.
·        So this can lead to improvement in the graft outcome as It minimize inflammatory process that causes DGF through preservation of endothelium and its integrity.
·       Cold pulsatile perfusion machine is most common modality used, especially for marginal and ECD and with DCD more than DBD.
·       The current study concluded that use of cold pulsatile machine perfusion was associated with decreased DGF, higher GFR than static cold storage especially in DCD.
·       Renal resistive index by Doppler US can help in predicting DGF (it increases in parallel manner to parenchymatous injury as it means microcirculatory damage).
·       Type of study: retrospective cohort (level III)
·       Limitations:
o  Retrospective.
o  Small sample size.
o  Single center.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  mai shawky
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Abdulrahman Ishag
Abdulrahman Ishag
2 years ago

 
Please provide a summary of this article

The study  aim;
was to evaluate the effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation in comparison to static cold storage based on a single centre experience.

The type of the study ;
Retrospective cohort study .

Ethical approval;
It was conducted in accordance with institutional ethics regulations; since it was a retrospective chart analysis, no informed consent was required.

Population ;
33 consecutive HMP kidney transplants and 33 cold stored kidney transplants .

The method ;

Retrospective analysis of 33 consecutive HMP kidney transplant outcomes matched with those of 33 cold stored:

1-delayed graft function (DGF), length of hospital stay (LOS), estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), and patient and graft survival were compared.

2- Renal Resistive Indexes (RIs) during HMP in relation to DGF were also analysed.

The results ;

1-DGF was lower in the HMP group , and donation after Circulatory Death (DCD) was a predictor for DGF .

2-HMP decreased DGF in DCD grafts . Patient and graft survival were similar, but eGFR at 365 days was higher in the HMP cohort .

3- RIs decreased during HMP ;
-hours RI ≥ 0.45 mmHg/mL/min predicted DGF in DCD kidneys
-hours RI ≥ 0.2 mmHg/ml/min predicted DGF in DBD grafts.

The limitations;

1-The small sample size .
2- it is a single centre study .

Conclusion ;

1-The study suggests that , the use of HMP resulted in the lower incidence of DGF, especially in the challenging DCD group.

2-The  study showed that the HMP cohort had significantly higher eGFRs at 365 days of follow up when compared to the CS group. Thus, the impact of DGF in the long-term outcome is elicited by the difference in the preservation techniques, particularly for kidneys from high risk donors, like DCDs.

3-The  study suggests that , the prevalence of the parenchymal damage in kidneys from DCD donors was demonstrated by the higher renal Resistive Index at 2 hours post HMP: 0.2 mmHg/ml/min for DBD versus 0.45 mmHg/ml/min for DCD.
 

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Abdulrahman Ishag
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Amit Sharma
Amit Sharma
2 years ago

Donation after cardiac death (DCD) is associated with increased rates of discard and delayed graft function (DGF). DGF has shown to be associated with prolonged hospital stay, reduced patient and graft survival and increased costs. Cold pulsatile perfusion is renoprotective by increasing endothelial nitric oxide release and decreasing secretion of endothelin-1.

The study was a retrospective, single centre study from March 2012 to April 2018, with an aim to compare the transplant outcomes in grafts using hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) with those of cold storage.

A total of 66 patients were included in the study, 33 each in both the arms. The baseline characteristics were similar in the 2 groups including the cold ischemia time. The comparison was done with respect to incidence of DGF, length of hospital stay, eGFR, patient survival and graft survival.

DGF: It was lower in the HMP group, especially in those with DCD implying that HMP had protective effect on DCD kidneys with respect to DGF.

Length of stay: It was longer in patients with DGF.

Renal resistance index (RI): It was significantly lower in those on HMP, especially between the first and second hour of HMP. 2-hour RI >0.2 mmHg/ml/min and >0.45 mmHg/ml/min for DBD and DCD grafts respectively was associated with DGF.

eGFR: The eGFR in 1st year post-transplant remained persistently higher in HMP group than the cold storage group.

Graft survival and patient survival: There was no significant difference among the 2 groups with respect to graft and patient survival.

The study concluded that HMP use is associated with reduced DGF rates, shorter hospital stays (due to lower DGFR rates) as well as better eGFR, when compared to cold storage.

The limitations of the study include: small sample size, single centre, retrospective nature of the study, and absence of details regarding the pre-implantation biopsy of the donors. HMP was not used randomly, but used only if there was an impediment to immediate transplant.

Level of evidence: Level 3

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Amit Sharma
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary. I note that you mention ‘limitations of this article’.

Manal Malik
Manal Malik
2 years ago

Summary of this article
Introduction
Donation after circulatory death (DCD) associated with 50%  delay graft function (DGF) compare to transplant organs from donor after brainstem death (DBD).
DGF is well a well established risk factor associated with reduced long -term graft and patient survival.
Use of machine perfusion technology has been associated with improved DGF rates ,especially for DCD organs.
Animal studies have demonstrated that one of the main benefits of using cold pulsatile perfusion ,is improved endothelin release of nitric oxide and reduced of endothelin ,result in Reno protective effect.
The aim of this study was to evaluate effect of HMP during kidney transplant preservation comparing to static cold storage on a single centre .
Retrospective cohort study analysis of HMP experience from march 2012 to April 2018 versus cold storage.
the case control were matched based on:
·        graft type(DBD or DCD).
·        Donor age .
·        Cold ischemia time.
·        Number of human leukocyte antigen mismatches between donor and recipients.
When kidneys in our centre there was an impediment to proceed immediately with the transplant between donor and recipients.
All patients received asteroid sparing immunosuppression regimen (7days course of steroid) with alemtuzumab induction and long -term tacrolimus monotherapy trough level 5-8.
Result
66 transplanted kidney outcomes were analysed.
No statistical difference was observed between HMP and CS group baseline characteristics
We sub analysed the difference in RIs between DCD and DBD grafts.
47 patients had a transplant follow up longer  than 365 -seven,20 in the HMO and 23 in  CS cohorts.
One graft loss occurred  in the HMP group at 180 days due to acute rejection.
3 graft lost in the CS cohort :venous thrombosis at 120 days postrenal transplant and acute rejection at 180.
In this study:
The protective role of HMP and related to reduced DGF rate .
Incidence of DGF was higher  in the CS compared to the HMPA.
Discussion
DGF of kidney transplantation from DCD donors affecting more than half of the transplanted graft . DGF was statistically significantly higher in the cold storage group and in DCD  grafts .RI is independent predictor during HMP for the later development of DGF ,however, it can not be a stand -alone tool in predicting DGF .recipient should be involved in the decision if the kidney from high risk donor.
Conclusion
Although  the small size of this study but the HMP and CS group found that hypothermic machine perfusion offers an advantage in deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys ,since it reduces significantly DGF rates and is associated with higher posttransplant eGFRs.
HMP has positive impact in kidney transplant outcome from DCD donors and offers an early viability assessment that allows prediction of short and long term, posttransplant graft function.

Doaa Elwasly
Doaa Elwasly
2 years ago

Introduction
DCD organs had higher risk of DGF in comparison to DBD organs, DGF  is associated with long-term graft and patient survival.
Machine perfusion decreases DGF rate specially in DCD organs .
DGF underlying pathology is donor ischemic injury and inflammatory signalling.
Cold pulsatile perfusion improves endothelial release of nitric oxide and reduced secretion of endothelin-1 leading to a renoprotective effect , unreachable  with standard static cold storage.
 Renal Resistance Index (RI) is a marker of the organ microcirculatory damage after the ischaemic injury, it’s monitoring is indicative of organ recovery during HMP.
Aim
Is to access the effect of HMP on the kidney preservation in comparison to static cold storage.
Methods
Retrospective cohort study on hypothermic machine perfused kidneys compared to cold storage for 6 years .
Case controls were matched according to graft type (DBD or DCD), donor age, cold ischaemic time(CIT), and number of Human  Leukocyte Antigen (HLA)mismatches.
Patients received a steroid sparing immunosuppressive regimen with alemtuzumab induction and long-term Tacrolimus (TAC) monotherapy.
Results
66 transplanted kidney outcomes were accessed .
DCD was an independent predictor for DGF .
DGF of  the DCD kidneys  in the HMP group were 5/12 and in the CS control  were 10/12 , showing a protective effect of the HMP preservation for the grafts  from DCD donors.
Patients with DGF had longer periods of hospital stay .
The effect of decrease  of RI value was mainly seen in the  first and  second hour of HMP.
 A 2-hours RI value ≥ 0.2mmHg/ml/min was accompanied with 100% sensitivity and 91% specifcity in DGF prediction for DBD grafts.
A 2-hours RI value ≥ 0.45 mmHg/ml/min was accompanied
with 75% sensitivity and 80% specifcity in DGF prediction
for DCD grafts.
e GFR  was higher in HMP compared to CS group.
Discussion
DGF is the main complication of DCD donors, that is why HMP is useful for DCD donors as it decreases DGF rate.
For DCD donors DGF incidence was lower with HMP compared to CS.
Cold pulsatile technology seems to be a better preservation method than static cold storage.
HMP was associated with higher e GFR revealing it’s protective short and long term effect.
HMP delivers oxygen or nutrients providing a chance for viability assessment indicating that it is more beneficial for high risk kidneys.
RI as  predictor during HMP cannot be the only factor to predict DGF but RI monitoring can assist in risk assessment.
RI reflects the microcirculatory damage in the renal parenchyma.
This data enable us to tailor the offered renal replacement therapy.
Conclusion
Hypothermic machine perfusion reduces DGF representing an advantage for deceased donor renal transplantation of high risk kidneys.
It provides viability assessment opportunity to predict short and long term graft outcome.

Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Doaa Elwasly
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary but it does not mention ‘limitations of article’.

Ban Mezher
Ban Mezher
2 years ago

Preservatives are important in reducing the incidence of DGF which can improve the survival of donated kidneys.Using of machine perfusion associated with improve DGF rate especially in DCD organs.
It was found that using cold pulsatile perfusion associated with Improve endothelial release of NO & reduce endothelia-1 secretion result in reno-protective effect which is not achieved by standard static cold storage ( animal studies).
RI can provide real time evaluation of organ recovery during HMP.

Patients & method:

  • Retrospective cohort analyst HMP transplant (March 2012-April 20184-5C) vise cols storage only.
  • Case control matched on 1:1 based according graft type (DBD vs DCD), donor age, CIT & number of HLA mismatch.
  • University of Wisconsin solution used for HMP at temp at 4-5C.
  • CIT define as time from cold perfusion to time of repercussion including HMP time.
  • eGFR calculated by MDRD.
  • All patient receive steroid spraying IS with alemtuzumab induction & tacrolimus as long term mono therapy.

Discussion:

  • DGF affect 50% of DCD donors.
  • DGF incidence found to be higher in CS compared to HMP.
  • Cold pulsatile technology is an alternative to static CS with better preservation method.
  • Use of HMP associated with lower rate of DGF especially in DCD with higher eGFR over 1 year of follow-up ( short & long term protective effect of HMP).
  • Pulsatile technology can reconditioning the graft making it good for higher risk kidney ( deliver O2, nutrients, or reconditioning agents).
  • The study demonstrate that parenchymal injury correlated with RI at 2 hr post HMP.
  • The study show the advantage of HMP by better outcome related to social & economic issue were important.
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Admin
Reply to  Ban Mezher
2 years ago

That is a well-typed summary but it does not mention ‘limitations of article’. Please typedheadings and sub-headings in bold or underline. That will make it easier to read.

98
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x